Some of us find it easier to give than receive. Since receiving really is a critical part of our first experience
(none of us would have survived infancy unless we'd received some care) I'm curious about why this can be such a challenge for many of us.
There's the obvious culprit: a dominator culture that values power-over tends to see the person who is giving as stronger and, by inference, the one who is receiving as weaker. The implication is that if you have something (time, energy, money, advice, insight, support, compassion etc.) to give, you must be doing something right, and if you need something you cannot provide for yourself, you must be doing something wrong. In part, this goes along with the cultural premium that is placed on independence- a fallacy if there ever was one in an inter-dependent world.
There's the obvious culprit: a dominator culture that values power-over tends to see the person who is giving as stronger and, by inference, the one who is receiving as weaker. The implication is that if you have something (time, energy, money, advice, insight, support, compassion etc.) to give, you must be doing something right, and if you need something you cannot provide for yourself, you must be doing something wrong. In part, this goes along with the cultural premium that is placed on independence- a fallacy if there ever was one in an inter-dependent world.
I
recently heard a news story about a ninety year old
woman who committed suicide because she knew that sometime in the
next few
years she would not be able to live
independently. Now, this is the kind of decision re:quality of life I want
to
leave up to individuals. Still, I could not help but wonder if the
collective value
we put on so-called independence might not make it difficult for those
of us living
in affluent parts of the world to see receiving assistance as we age not
only as loss, but also as a way to learn something together. I have gone through periods
when illness has necessitated relying heavily on friends and family for
care. My delusion of self-sufficiency was shattered, and nothing has
softened my heart more to myself and others than needing and receiving
help.
Of
course receiving, depending on the situation, can sometimes feel
unsafe. As discussed in last week’s blog, "Giving Without Resentment,"
giving is sometimes (consciously or not)
done in a bid to gain power over another or as a way to make a bargain-
goods
or consideration for later unspecified favours. If these deals are vague and
unspoken we can end up feeling we owe another, unsure of what exactly is
expected.
But
the truth is, as adults, another’s expectations are only
our problem if we buy into them. If someone gives me something, my role
is to
receive it as graciously and as freely as possible. If that person comes
back
later expecting or pulling for something in exchange that was not agreed
to, I need to sit with whether or not I can or want to give what is
requested, and
to be clear that there was no agreed-to exchange. If this happens
repeatedly
with another, I will ask that implicit deals be made explicit before
receiving.
(If you cook me dinner are you expecting something in return?) If this
still leaves the other expecting
something unspecified in return for giving I may reconsider receiving
from this particular
person
Honestly, if we stay conscious about and aren’t drawn into
obligations we never agreed to, the other will stop trying to create unspoken bargains simply because it’s not working for
them.
But
what if someone wants to give us something
we don't need or want? Well, the first option is to simply say, “No,
thank you,”
particularly if what is offered is going to create any suffering (Eg.- a
visit,
even with someone we love, can be draining when we are ill.) We can
receive and
appreciate the caring intent but let the other know this is not
something we
can or want to receive right now. Of course, if we know what we need, the
next step is to ask for it- post-graduate work for many of us leery of
receiving.
"We accept the love we feel we deserve," is a line from the movie The Perks of Being a Wallflower. Perhaps, if we are reluctant receivers, it is because we have been taught to believe that we are not deserving- a belief worth challenging as we learn to cherish ourselves.
The sad thing about not trusting our boundaries and our right to say "Yes please," or "No thank you," is that we may develop the habit of being non-receptive, of not really taking in what is offered and allowing it to replenish us each day. This can leave anyone who is giving feeling unreceived and the receiver strangely hungry for what is offered but not really received.
We cannot help but be both givers and
receivers every day. And the world we co-create is largely shaped and coloured
by how we are with ourselves and each other in our giving and
receiving. Both can create knots of obligation and resentment or cultivate open-hearted
joy and gratitude.
Today, may we take in with gratitude and without fear that which we choose to receive, and may we give without resentment that which we can offered in a truly sustainable way.
Today, may we take in with gratitude and without fear that which we choose to receive, and may we give without resentment that which we can offered in a truly sustainable way.
Oriah (c) 2013